As the Puddin Churns

You can't handle this bowl.

Archive for April 2010

Hockey, Wrestling and Me

leave a comment »

Recently on the chlforums site, a Bucks fan went off on a rant about Brian Benway – the “Voice” of the Laredo Bucks.  The fan called Benway “Gay Pee Wee” [as in Pee Wee Herman] and talked about how his play-by-play sucked and how Laredo needed a new media guy.  [Here, why don't you just go look at the thread yourself?]

Anyway, I decided to chime in on this subject because I too find Benway to be pretty annoying and un-professional.  I can’t stand to listen to the guy on the radio and I’ve stopped reading his blog a long time ago.  For a professional broadcaster and public relations rep, he can’t speak or write for shit.  Now, I wouldn’t personally insult him like the Laredo fan, but I don’t think he’s fit for his job. That’s my opinion.

Then I brought up wrestling.

You see, Benway is a huge wrestling fan.  He has mentioned it numerous times in his blog and I’ve heard him talk about it during his broadcasts [hey, sometimes CHL TV leaves me no choice but to listen to him].  I think it’s pretty immature for a grown man to be a wrestling fan.  It’s entertainment for tweens and teens, not adults with jobs.  I also think that this immaturity shines through in what he does on-the-job for the Bucks.

Well, Rich Bocchini, the broadcaster and media guy for the Killer Bees, read those comments and felt the need to come to Benway’s defense.  let me quote him directly here:

  • As far as Benway being a WWE fan, what does that have to do with anything? I am a big fan of pro wrestling. I’m not embarrassed about it one bit and neither should Benway be. I watch it and often read the autobiographies wrestlers have written. I also read a lot of political books. During the course of the season, I find watching and reading about wrestling a fun, mindless escape from the day-to-day grind. Now, maybe some people expect that play-by-play guys just go home and watch more hockey. Sometimes I do. But I get tired of it. I love the game, just like I love steak. But if I worked at Morton’s Steakhouse I doubt I’d want to go home and eat a ribeye every night (OK, maybe I would).
  • According to the posts about Benway, somehow being a ‘rasslin fan equals being immature. Really? How is it any different than going home and watching Lost, or American Idol or Ghost Hunters? Yes, it’s “fake” (by the way, try telling a wrestler what they do is “fake”) and  it’s silly, but it’s fun. I think some of the stuff they do is pretty amazing (check out this move) and to be honest, they can incur some pretty serious injuries.
  • Ok, Rich, since I can’t comment on the Killer Bee site directly, I’ll respond here and send you a link.
    I don’t consider that you broadcast/media guys eat, breathe and live hockey.  It’s ok that you don’t.  My point is that you are professional men, fully grown.  What appeal can wrestling possibly hold for you?  Let’s forget about the fact that it’s fake for a minute.  Lots of things are fake, TV shows, movies, books, etc. Why do I hold wrestling in such low regard in comparison?
    Well, you brought up Lost, which is actually my favorite show on TV right now.  I like the story and the scientific/philosophical/metaphysical ideas it brings up.  So you are saying that being a fan of wrestling is no different than being a fan of Lost.  Sorry, but I whole-heartedly disagree -except for one instance where you might be right; maybe this exception will help you understand where I’m coming from:
    There is a particular group of Lost fans who call themselves “shippers,” because they support a particular relationSHIP on the the show.  You have your Jaters who want Jack and Kate together.  Then you have your Skaters who want Sawyer and Kate.  There are other factions, but you get the idea.  These factions spend a lot of time back and forth in discussion forums arguing about which ‘ship is the best, which characters have the best chemistry, which characters made love, etc, etc, ad nauseum.  These are not teenagers, for the most part.  These are mostly women in their 20′s and 30′s. To me this behavior is not to far from that of wrestling fans; very immature.
    Lost is a story and a damn good one at that.  It’s filled with thought-provoking ideas, great dialogue and superb acting.  However,  I have no rooting interest in the show other than the fact that I like it and want to see it continue.  When Jack and Kate kiss on the show, I don’t get all excited and squeal.  When something major happens plotwise, I don’t stand up and yell and cheer and scream.  Wrestling fans and ‘Shippers do all of this.  They create a rooting interest.   They forget that they are being told a story.  I think this is extremely immature behavior.
    Now, if you can watch wrestling merely as a mindless entertainment, then fine.  Even I can admit to admiring some of the moves they pull off and certainly there is some element of danger.  If you like that then, “To each their own,” right?  But if you: stand up and boo when the “heels” enter the ring, cheer like crazy when the “faces” show up, yell and high-five with every body slam and piledriver, pay $49.95 to watch the various PPV, pay ridiculous sums for ringside seats, walk around in t-shirts with your favorite wrestler, inject your everyday conversations with wrestling anecdotes, talk about wrestling on-air and in your blogs, etc.  then I say you are immature.  Sorry, but that’s what I think.

    Written by puddinman

    April 14, 2010 at 2:58 pm

    Follow

    Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.